Aug 272014
 

Bruichladdich Scottish Barley176

50% abv

Score:  86/100

 

Bruichladdich is no stranger to No Age Statement whisky.  In fact over the past ten or twelve years they’ve probably been one of the most visible proponents of the concept.  I think this approach was first viewed by the distillery as a necessary maneuver in order to get whisky on the shelves throughout the first decade of production after their 2001 reopening.

Considering how fundamentally opposed I am to the idea of opaque marketing with whisky, I imagine it’s somewhat surprising (even to myself, if I’m to be honest) how much I adore and support Bruichladdich.

Let’s face it…no other distillery has done as much to reinvigorate the whisky world over the last few years as Bruichladdich.  They’ve pushed hard for higher bottling strengths – first 46% as a standard, and now 50%.  They’ve foregone artificial colouring.  They’ve made a mockery of the concept of chill-filtration.  Their employment of local labour is staggering, especially viewed in contrast to the two-man crews running some of Diageo’s multi-million litre producers.  Their innovative cask play, phenol manipulation (and exploitation!), terroir-first approach, experiments with organic barley, unprecedented guerrilla marketing, over-the-top bottle designs and simply unparalleled passion are more than enough reason to keep dollars flowing from my bank account into theirs.   There’s no two ways about it.  Bruichladdich have made whisky exciting.  I do begrudge them the NAS thing, but absolutely support them in perpetuity for everything else.

So that’s Bruichladdich.  Now let’s talk about this Bruichladdich: the new Scottish Barley core release.  This malt supercedes 2011’s Laddie 10, the distillery’s first proper 10 year old under the new regime.  Unfortunately, if all the sources I’ve culled are correct, Bruichladdich simply couldn’t keep production at a level that would support an ongoing 10 year old at this time.  That particular malt was met with such positive acclaim and widespread demand that the distillery finally had to step away from the idea of the Laddie 10 as their core expression and back up a few steps into the NAS territory again to give themselves some breathing room.  The Laddie 10 is still available at the distillery, from what I understand.

Oh well.  There are worse problems to have than overwhelming demand, I suppose.

The logical first question would most likely be whether or not the Scottish Barley is a step down from the Laddie 10.  And I honestly wish I could answer that for you.  Unfortunately I don’t have a bottle of the Laddie 10 open at the moment.  In a couple weeks time I will be able to try them head to head and assess which comes out on top.  There may be slight score adjustments to the respective reviews at that time.  Either way…that score is a personal assessment.  Don’t get hung up on the number.  Instead, just read the tasting notes below.  At the end of the day, though, this is a really good whisky.  Well worth your time.  Well worth your money.

Nose:  Orange.  Maybe a vague touch of tangerine or something semi-tropical.  Scone dough.  Very mild vanillins.  Rosewater Turkish Delight.  Lemon.  The barley is still recognizable through it all.  Sweet and balanced.

Palate:  Some nice heat on arrival.  Barley sugar sweetness up front.  A nice candied fruit follows.  Grassy Sauvignon Blanc tones.  A very slight (but very nice) fuel note that dissipates with time in the glass.  Still getting some orange.  A touch of pepper.  Toothpick and apple skin.  Quite drying.  None too complex, but doesn’t need to be.

Thoughts:  This is NAS, so the immediate assumption is youth, and while there is certainly a heft of young whisky in here, I think there are a few slightly older casks thrown in to add a little softness and knock the edges off a bit.

 

– Reviewed by:  Curt

– Photo:  Curt

 Posted by at 8:39 am

  9 Responses to “Bruichladdich Scottish Barley Review”

  1. I thought the Laddie 10 was terrific, and a great value. Was sorry to see it replaced. Just went hunting to see if I had a heel of both and I don’t. Look forward to your thoughts, but suspect the 10 will edge the SB just slightly!

  2. Still 120 of the Laddie 10 in Ontario…mind you only 9 in the city of Toronto. There were 400 about a month ago so people are probably beginning to stock up for the famine (drought?).

    I know someone who has 2 here, pristine, unopened…. And I know someone in Calgary who doesn’t like his opened bottle and wants to get rid of it…

    • I have said Laddie 10s, but here in Ontario I only see the Port Charlotte Scottish Barley.

      I’ve tried the 10 in Calgary (said open bottle) but I think I like the Laddie Classic better. I have an open one and almost bought a spare in cowtown this summer. It’s cheaper, too.

  3. I understand the supply issues, but the Laddie 10 is an excellent whisky for 10 years. I have a bottle stashed with my Longmorn 15, red stripe Laphroaig CS, Glenlivet Nadurra Triumph, etc.
    for a future date. Look forward to it returning to general distribution.

    Now before summer is gone, you need to review a few bourbons, such as Evan Williams Single Barrel and Elijah Craig Barrel Proof. Great buys for great whiskies! If you like the Rare Breed nose, you’ll die for the ECSB nose. I’m a big WT fan, but it is even better.

  4. Great Review. We are trying this Bruichladdich expression at the end of September. Looking forward to it as it looks interesting. The colour of the bottle is really unusual and stands out between the normal whisky bottles. 🙂

    Jeannette
    http://whiskyoftheweek.co.uk/

  5. Did you end up making the comparison with the Laddie Ten? Thoughts? Would really like to know if one has more to offer than the other.

  6. I had the pleasure of a bottle of the 10 year as a birthday gift around 2003. It was magnificent. With efforts was not able to get anouther one. Now sitting on my porch I am sampling a recent purchase of the Scottish Barly……not bad but not what I remembered. Perhaps my palate has been changed, and to that I believe more refined as I have sample many more whiskeys including blends. My opinion…it has changed and not for the better of my taste. Not sure why this is but my truck has confirmed that the simple and available Glenfidich and Glenlivit are still the absolute leaders of single malt. Also will choose Chivas, Sewers 12, Dimple Pinch, and Buchannans above this in terms of flavor and price. This assessment is surprising to me but honest. I will now revil in the fact that price and hype will not surpass real flavor and taste.f rank

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)